Hand-Selected Recipes and Stories Straight to Your Inbox

Serving up Old Fashioneds at The Pendennis Club

Birch Street Uptown Lounge

Serving up Old Fashioneds at The Pendennis Club

|

Where to drink the best Old Fashioneds in the South

Love bourbon? Good. Us, too. When you're ready to take a break from drinking it neat, head out to these 8 bars to sample some of the best Old Fashioneds around the South.

The Old Fashioned — a mix of bourbon or rye, sugar and bitters — is a classic Southern cocktail that was invented in the late 19th century in Louisville. Legend has it that the cocktail was created at The Pendennis Club and was named for Col. James E. Pepper, who was a patriarch of Kentucky bourbon whiskey. Today, there are plenty of Southern bars and restaurants that are mixing up their own version of the classic cocktail. 

Here are some of our favorites: 

610 Magnolia, Louisville
Unfortunately, it’s almost impossible to sample the original Old Fashioned, as the Pendennis is a private club, notes Garden & Gun. Instead head over to another Louisville restaurant and bar to sip on this cocktail. A New American bistro located in historic Old Louisville, 610 Magnolia serves up an Old Fashioned that rivals the original.
610 Magnolia is at 610 W Magnolia Ave., Louisville. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook and Instagram.

Cask and Larder, Orlando
Cask and Larder’s cocktail program is inventive and strays away from mixing up basic classic cocktails, which is probably why it has been included on Condé Nast Traveler’s 8 Best Cocktail Bars in the South. Its version of an Old Fashioned is the Public House Old Fashioned, which is made with brown butter-infused Old Forester bourbon and smoked simple syrup. 
Cask and Larder is at Orlando International Airport, Southwest Airlines Gates 100-129. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook and Instagram.

Silo, Nashville
Located in Nashville’s Germantown neighborhood, this Southern-influenced bistro is a local favorite for specialty cocktails, including creative takes on the Old Fashioned. In the past, the menu featured Whiskey & Pearls — a deconstructed Old Fashioned, with the house bitters presented in caviar that are resting at the bottom of the drink and garnished with a flamed orange. Currently on the menu is the Bartender’s Old Fashioned, made with your choice of Buffalo Trace, Ilegal Reposado or Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum, simple syrup, Angostura bitters and orange express.
Silo is at 1121 5th Ave. N, Nashville. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook and Instagram.

Arnaud’s French 75 Bar, New Orleans
This bar was once designated as a “gentlemen only area” back in the day. Now anyone can enjoy its fancy cocktails and inventive drinks, including an Old Fashioned. Also on the menu at the moment is the El Guapo Fashioned, made with Jim Bean, Meletti Amaro, Cocktail & Sons Herbed Demerara, and El Guapo bitters.
Arnaud's is at 813 Bienville St., New Orleans. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook and Instagram.

9 Mile Station, Atlanta
The beer garden located on the roof of Ponce City Market offers more than just beer. The cocktail menu is small, but the drinks created by its mixologist Randy Hayden are consistently great. At 9 Mile Station, there are three versions of Old Fashioneds to try, so you better get drinking.
9 Mile Station is on the rooftop at 675 Ponce De Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Heirloom Restaurant, Charlotte
The farm-to-table mentality flows from the dinner menu to the cocktail menu at Heirloom. On Heirloom’s cocktail menu, the Old Fashioned is currently made with beeswax-infused Doc Porter’s bourbon, Crude’s “Pooter” bitters and Savory Spice Shop’s barrel-smoked sugar. 
Heirloom Restaurant is at 8470 Bellhaven Blvd., Charlotte. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Kimball House, Decatur, GA
At Kimball House, the cocktail menu is constantly changing, as its bartenders challenge themselves to create and serve perfect drinks. One of the creative cocktails they’ve invented is the pecan Old Fashioned.
Kimball House is at 303 East Howard Ave., Decatur. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Empire State South, Atlanta
The Old Fashioned at Empire State South is one of the restaurant’s most popular cocktails. Its housemade Old Fashioned syrup is what sets it apart from the other cocktails. The restaurant's beverage director, Kellie Thorn, told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution: “The simple syrup we created for our Old Fashioned muddles lemon and orange peels into the raw sugar and bitters mixture. The floral tones from the citrus expressions in the syrup really highlight the floral notes of the whiskey.”
Empire State South is at 999 Peachtree St. NE #140, Atlanta. Connect with the restaurant on Facebook and Instagram.

Photos courtesy of Facebook. 


Author image

Rachel Taylor is a staff writer at Southern Kitchen. She moved to Atlanta earlier this year after graduating college in Maryland, and has been a digital audience specialist at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and Politically Georgia, as well as a freelance writer for publications such as USA Today and the Delmarva Daily Times on Maryland's Eastern Shore. She has lived in France and Italy, and loves to travel.

Shop our goods

SK_Icons

Southern Kitchen hand selects top maker and artisan goods for your kitchen and home